Blog Home AastanaBlog: Member's Area 

Share your Quranic thoughts, research and knowledge with other's.
It's free, easy and only takes a minute.
Sign up Now
Member ID:
Member Since : 8/2010
59 Questions QUESTIONS
Question from Facebook, what is WUDHU ? Rub your head? clean your face with dirt? Date : 03/04/2012

Question from Facebook, what does the numbers in 9:36 means Date : 03/04/2012

From Facebook, IS THE QURAN CHANGED AND IT IS DIVINE ? Date : 03/04/2012

SA Had some discussions on Facebook, going to post some of the notes and replies here WHAT IS RUKOOH ? Date : 03/04/2012

Dear readers, sharing a post from FB, the traditional view on 4:34 vs Astana's version. plz correct mistakes Date : 10/03/2012

Mohammed tufail shad said : Khata Munna Nabiyyeen(Muhammad Salam unn Alaih) Before starting the actual topic we must under stand the root word of KHAA TA M (which is Kha Ta Ma). Date : 01/03/2012

Salaam wabarokato,someone asked, why s Ibrahim is called Umma 16:20, and what mutshabia means in 39:23 Date : 29/02/2012

question asked:- could 'ma tashabaha minHU' be 'min Allah' rather than 'min al-kitab'. After all, Allah is the doer of this aya.(3:7) Date : 29/02/2012

someone asked , ayat no 3:21,, the word used is فَبَشِّرْهُم which is translated to khush khabri, glad tidings, why is it translated to khush khabri if its related to azaab? Date : 29/02/2012


Why is this word بِآيَاتِ written different Date : 19/12/2011

Please explain 114:1-6 Date : 04/12/2011

Two members of Aastana blog failed to back up their claims with proofs, however, if anyone from their group, or someone having the same view as them, or use the orthodox translation based on hadith while they reject hadith, then please answer Date : 02/12/2011

4:22 ,Why is marriage withالنِّسَاءِ of آبَاؤُكُمْ called فَاحِشَةً وَمَقْتًا وَسَاء سَبِيلاً Date : 24/09/2011

Dear all ,What exactly is unachievable in the mentioned attributes of Rusools and Nabis and what did they do to get wahy....? Date : 12/09/2011

وَالتِّينِ وَالزَّيْتُونِ وَطُورِ سِينِينَ لَقَدْ خَلَقْنَا الْإِنسَانَ فِي أَحْسَنِ تَقْوِيمٍ please explain :O?? Date : 05/09/2011

Dear friends, I do not understand why gender is emphasized in witness stuff, what if the witness is "neuter"? and who is "first" witness and who is "second" witness, how did the Quran define the difference? Can't the same situation happen with men? Date : 31/08/2011

Dear Moazzam brother, Please explain 35:33,76:12-21 ,,silk...gold...pearls...:):):):):):)Do I have to die before I get it :(??? Date : 06/07/2011

Dear Dear ones, is there anything called "soul" in the Quran? Explain like im two years old, here i need spoon feeding or feedingbottle. Date : 26/05/2011

«»Page no. 2 of 3
824 Comments/Replies COMMENTS / REPLIES
Why do you think its forces of nature, because Allama Parwez said it?
Date : 03/01/2019>>View Detail

sectarians who refer to themselves as Muslims but follow hadith or hadith based translations can believe what they want
Date : 23/05/2018>>View Detail

Yes they are people of authority. The word MALAIKA have the root M-L-K which means “power, strength, force, potency, might etc.  
The orthodox explanation about MALAIKA is saying that they are super natural beings,wonders or paranormal entities with wings and they have an ability to change their features. They are invisible, general public are not tooled with an apparatus to get the drift of these uncanny creatures- They can travel hundreds of miles in short time, they can behead the enemy just like that, they cut of the enemies fingers just like that, still it is strange that in war, while Momineens were fighting with the enemy, they are sent in a huge quantity, from one thousand to five thousand.  
The Quran is free from myths and fairy tales.  
In surah Anfaal aya no 9 it is stated that they were sent in a huge amount, about one thousand. In surah al Imran it is stated they were sent in an amount of 3000 (124) and then it is stated it was sent as many as 5000 (125)  
What kind of soldiers or army does the enemy have since Allah had to send that many MALAIKAs (claimed to be super natural with the above mentioned attributes) against them (In addition to the already fighting Momineens)?  
If one is to ponder, according to the attributes MALAIKAs are said to possess in the orthodox interpretation, it should be enough with only ONE MALAIKA against the army of enemies (of human beings.)  
The truth is that MALAIKAs are not super natural beings, they are human beings.

Date : 10/04/2018>>View Detail

#F20D96 its only to check if there are any mistakes or if something is overlooked, what won't happen is that religious concepts will be smuggled into it, so a good step for you will be not to wait for that lol
Date : 13/09/2017>>View Detail

It with heavy heart that we inform you of Dr.Qamar Zaman`s demisehe died peacefully surrounded by his family . But rest assured the work with the Quran will continue because the linguistics team will NEVER let this work go to waste. The Quran has been finished by Dr. Qamar Zaman and is still intact with the team with the finished, polished, and edited version
Date : 03/07/2017>>View Detail

Hamid Gul I'm glad you liked my questions, and thank you for the lectures. I'm glad we have wise people here who can instruct us when we are going astray.  
BKanwar, who misinterpreted you :O ?
Date : 07/02/2017>>View Detail

"The concept of Allah is not easy to grasp. There is no limit in scope of its thinking/imagination. However, study of nature can bring us near to comprehension. More we think of Allah by study of nature, more we evolve ourselves."  
HOW? How can u understand the concept of "Allah" ? What information about Allah do you get by studying the nature? And what's relevant to our subject (the Quran) what information is provided ABOUT Allah, the concept and how did the author prophets, know? What did they study to get information about Allah, who is the "cretor" so he must have existed before he created us.... how can we ever understand something that we can't even study/analyze? The prophets must have provided evidence for their claims, what did they say?
Date : 20/01/2017>>View Detail

We can't really understand the creator by studying the creation, we can understand the creation by studying it? And then probably come to a conclusion that there is a force behind this that started it all. But that's our belief, we won't get any verified information about the creator. This concept is from the translators who distorted rest of the message...
Date : 17/01/2017>>View Detail

do you suggest we should ignore how the word is used? If you read the translation linked on the left side of this page, it will be clear why Allah is thought to be a law creating authority.  
Date : 13/01/2017>>View Detail

Hamid Gul said:- Hakumat " means Government , so government of ilaha , if there is no ilaha as Bkanwar2 suggested , than who are going to establish such a government to rule people ?***  
Bkanwar said :- There is no illah or god as understood in traditional sense according to Quran.  
As u can see brother Bkanwar is saying there is no Ilah or God as in traditional sense and we agree. Ilah or Allah is NOT God in the religious sense.  
Sectarians (who follow hadith, history, trad translations) believe Allah and Ilah is God, when u fast and pray he is happy. When ur a gay he can flip and destroy ur city ... sometimes he sends angels sometimes he reduce 50 namaaz to 5... Because prophet Musa knew better than Allah.  
We don't think Allah used in the Quran fit this ^^ definition or description. Please search on the page for discussions of Allah ilah and check lexicons for the meanings. Aastana's is not just looking at the words isolated from the context, to get the complete picture we must also see how the Quran used the word. Whats Allah doing? What's the function of Rabb, what is he doing? In what sense or context is Ilah used ? and so on  
IF the Quran say that Allah ordered the prophets to confront the pharaohs, elites, clergy, royalties (whoever controlling the resources and enslaving mankind) and help people to establish a different and better administration that lead to collective progress, then it is clearly not corporation. So just because the existing governments are enslaving mankind, it doesn't mean "Quranic government" is same.  
But that's discussed on the blog before, a quick search will help. If you read the old discussions it may help to understand the difference between the rule of elite,kings, clergy (all in favor of those who are in power/those who made the laws) blahblah VS the rule of law based on wahy (the system of justice and equality)
Date : 12/01/2017>>View Detail

«»Page no. 1 of 83
Blog Home Question Explorer Member's Area Mission & Vision Join AASTANABLOG
© 2006-2010 Aastana e Research and Understanding Quran. All Rights Reserved